Jump to content
  • entries
    940
  • comments
    5,894
  • views
    863,942

Oculus Rift vs. HTC Vive: Which is the one true VR headset?


Josh

2,986 views

 Share

I recently picked up an Oculus Rift (CV1) in order to improve our support for this headset. It was easy to make my changes, but having the actual hardware on hand was invaluable in this process, and our support for the Rift is now much better because of this. I have now tried a total of five different VR headsets:

  • HTC Vive
  • Valve's duct-taped prototype that was the basis of the HTC Vive.
  • Oculus Rift DK1
  • Oculus Rift DK2
  • Oculus Rift CV1

At one point Leadwerks Game Engine actually worked with the DK2 but at the time I chose not to release this feature.

So I've worked with a wide range of VR hardware going back several years, and here's what I think.

Oculus-Rift-vs-HTC-Vive-4.jpg.7477590f16f88dda6bb2fcd53ca311be.jpg

Ergonomics

The Oculus Rift has improved substantially over earlier prototypes with comfortable straps, built-in headphones, and an easy setup. The Rift feels like a polished consumer product while the Vive feels not quite as refined. The most annoying thing about the Vive are the earbuds, which add an extra cord and get tangled up in the headset cord going to the computer. Even worse, one of my earbud covers fell off, I lost it, and now I am using the included smaller set so the headphones tend to fall out of my ears while I am playing.

Winner: Oculus Rift

Ease of Setup

With the Oculus Rift, you just plug the headset into an HDMI port and a USB port, plug both motion trackers into USB ports, and you're done. The HTC Vive, on the other hand, can be overwhelming when you open the box. It uses a base station which increases the number of wires, and the lighthouse tracking units require some thought on how and where to put them. I bought two photography tripods and have my lighthouse units mounted on top of those.

The Oculus Rift involves a total of three cables, while the HTC Vive uses twice as many.

Winner: Oculus Rift

Display

Both headsets feature a 2160x1200 OLED screen. I feel like the screen-door effect is less severe on the Oculus but both are good. Contrast in lighting levels can cause reflections in the Vive that form concentric rings around your pupil. The Rift also has reflections but these take the form of "godrays" that appear to be moving in towards your eye.

Winner: Oculus Rift

Controllers

The Vive controller is like a combination of a Wii wand and a Steam controller. It's cool to see the haptic touchpad from the Steam controller onto something else. You can do some cool things like split the touchpad up into four buttons. The Oculus Touch controllers are really nice. You can make several poses with your hands including closing and opening your hands and pointing your index finger. The controllers aren't ambidextrous and they feel very different from the Vive wands. Plus, they only take up about half the space when you set them down on any surface.  However, the pose they force your hand into feels unnatural and I can easily see how these would cause discomfort after extended usage.

Winner: Tie

Tracking

The HTC Vive is built for room-scale tracking. You can freely walk around an area up to 15'x15' and only have to worry about tripping over your cord or running into a wall. The Rift, on the other hand, uses two forward-facing motion trackers with a much smaller 7'x7' area. The most annoying thing about the Rift is you have to keep facing the motion sensors or you will lose tracking. Some games continuously warn you to turn around and face the sensors, which really limits the kinds of games you can enjoy with the Rift. So with the Vive you just have to worry about not running into walls, but with the Rift you have a smaller area and you also have to consider your rotation in VR and in the real world while playing, which really breaks the immersion.

Winner: HTC Vive

Conclusion

Both headsets are good. The Oculus Rift is a polished version of the original Oculus DK1, while the HTC Vive is a less refined headset with more advanced tracking capabilities. The Rift is $200 cheaper and is probably better for seated VR experiences, while the Vive allows room-scale games and experiences the Rift can't match with its limited tracking technology.

  • Like 2
 Share

5 Comments


Recommended Comments

I tried both the Rift and Vive and I find the Rift to me more ideal as not everyone has the space to do full room scale VR. I had issues playing Job Simulator, but I could play Robo Recall just fine (Minus me punching my ceiling light from time to time :))

The god ray effect on the Rift is AWFUL. I didn't notice them at first, but when I did, I thought my device was defective. 

Link to comment

You can add additional Rift cameras to have the ability to rotate completely.
Also having the cords will always limit your rotation freedom. no matter if Rift or Oculus.

Since i have not used the Vive controllers yet but having used the Playstation ones that are also in the form of a wand, i must say the Oculus Controllers are a lot more natural in controlling. And if you use the correct Left controller for the left hand and the right controller for the right hand, they fit naturally into your hand. No "unnatural pose" here. You can point naturally at something and your avatar in game does also point exactly there. With a "wand" you have to point the tip of the wand at something. Probably more like a remote control.

The only thing i didn't liked about the oculus setup yet, was since i have a very small room i could not activate the out of bounds warning, because the oculus software was always telling me i can only activate it when the room is big enough. Why that? When i have a huge room, i don't have to be that careful to hit things anyway. ;)

 

Link to comment
Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...